Part III: Text-based and PowerPoint Resumes
Exploring alternative resume formats
Job seekers have so many formatting choices including: MS Word, .pdf, rich text format, online resumes with distinct URL’s, video resumes, PowerPoint slide show presentations and online company applications. Which are most effective? What do recruiters REALLY want to see?
To date, I’ve asked 24 recruiters and hiring managers from around the globe who have respectfully weighed in on the topic. This week’s focus is on resumes created in text-based and PowerPoint formats.
Text-based and PowerPoint resumes – defined
Text-based resumes are those that you create in programs such as Wordpad or Notepad and/or save with .txt or .rtf extensions. They are absent of any formatting styles such as color, bold, italics, underlining, bullets, headers, footers, and related.
By contrast, MS PowerPoint (PPT) provides a full range of formatting options including everything a text-based program will not. PowerPoint allows you to create a brief set of slides (as few as 1 or 2) to display your resume content as a slide show in which you can control the timing from slide to slide, any animations in play, and more.
Pros and cons of text-based resumes
Text-based resumes are boring. There is virtually nothing about them that will attract and hold attention. So why are they used? Two words: compatibility and compliance. Rarely are acronyms like ASCII seen as a submission requirement anymore, which indicated a basic or older applicant tracking system was in use or was intended to ward off viruses and corrupted files. Current virus protection programs and the improved stability of MS Word have alleviated most of those concerns.
Ken Winters, CEO and Founder of Staffback.com and Hireway.com out of the San Francisco Bay area, advises job seekers that, “Text and Rich Text resumes are OK but I have seen some hiring managers look down on them because they are quite plain when compared to Word and .PDF documents.
He compares it to “seeing a car without paint… it gets the driver from point A to B, but it sure looks funny driving by”. He also adds, “Using these plain formats for Marketing and Communications type positions would result in instant rejection. With the ability to create Word docs for free in Google docs, there really is only one reason to have a Text or Rich Text resume: some Applicant Tracking Systems/websites require that plain text be entered in the resume box, so for that reason, it is nice to have a copy of your resume handy on your PC in a plain text format.”
He concludes by indicating that compared to MS Word and .pdf formats, “Plain text based resumes sit in a distant third spot“. So, while widely compatible, text-based resumes simply cannot compete with MS Word or .pdf formats when it comes to conveying visual impact.
Steve Anderson, Managing Director of C. Anderson Associates in St. Paul, agrees and says “Almost without exception, employers know how to handle .doc files. It can be easily edited with Word, GoogleDocs, Open Office, etc. The same is true for .rtf, but .doc is more recognizable. As for .txt, you lose a lot of formatting options, so I have never received a resume in .txt“.
Of all the recruiters interviewed, no one indicated a preference or even a genuine appreciation for text-based resumes.
However, if you copy/paste your Word resume into online application forms, the receiving system generally converts your content into a text-based format, which is perfectly acceptable, as it indicates how a prospective employer’s applicant tracking system needs to handle your information.
Pros and cons of PowerPoint resumes
The overall feedback on PowerPoint resumes was mostly poor and cautious at best. For example:
Steve Anderson says of PowerPoint resumes, “PPT is for presentations and no one likes to sit through presentations in the first place.” Therefore, it should never be sent as a first point of contact.
Ken Winters, warns, “PowerPoint resumes are absolutely not acceptable as many hiring managers do not have PPT on their PC. It is an expensive program and is not included in the lower tier MS Office Suite packages.”
However, PPT can be perfectly acceptable as a follow-up bonus if you know it will be accepted by the receiver. Ken adds, “Anything submitted in PPT should only come after being requested, such as a 90 day marketing plan or other types of work samples in professions that use this format“. So, if you’re applying for an Executive Assistant position and will need to produce PowerPoint presentations for your new boss, sending a professionally prepared sample can set you apart from your competition.
Tip: You can also have your resume available in LinkedIn using multiple formats and uploaded through the Box.net application. For example, you can load your resume in Word (using both .doc and .docx extensions, separately) .pdf, PowerPoint, text-based format, etc. This allows recruiters and hiring managers to select their preferred format. An added benefit: the Box.net application will alert you by email whenever one of your documents is downloaded and viewed so you can see for yourself which versions capture the most interest.
Stay tuned…
These hiring professionals provided such a wealth of information, this topic quickly turned into a multi-part series, weighing the pros and cons of multiple resume formats, so stay tuned for all installments, and go back and read both Part I and Part II. Next up: online company application methods.
VIEW Part IV at: http://changeyourjob.us/wordpress/?p=119
-Lisa
